A probate court does not care what the car sold for at Barrett-Jackson last spring. It cares what the vehicle was worth on the date of death, who said so, and whether that person can defend the number if opposing counsel or a beneficiary pushes back.

Most vehicle appraisals submitted in estate matters fail on one of four points. Here is what those are, what a defensible report looks like, and what to send us to open an engagement.

The four things that get estate vehicle appraisals rejected

1. The wrong effective date

The most common problem we see in reports submitted by other appraisers: the effective date is the inspection date, not the date of death.

These are not the same number. A 1969 Camaro Z/28 appraised on March 15 for an estate where the decedent died on November 3 of the prior year needs a November 3 value — not a March value. Collector car markets move. A four-month gap in a rising market can mean a $15,000 difference on a single vehicle.

A defensible estate appraisal locks the effective date to the date of death. That date is stated in the report. The comparable sales used to support the value are drawn from the period surrounding that date — not from whenever the appraiser got around to writing the report.

2. The intended user is not named

USPAP requires that an appraisal identify its intended users. A report that says "prepared for the estate of [name]" without naming the attorney of record or the estate as the intended user creates a problem: opposing counsel can argue the report was not prepared for the purpose it is being used.

We name the attorney of record, the estate, or both as intended users. We state the intended use — estate inventory, probate filing, trust administration — in the scope of work section. This is not boilerplate. It is the language that keeps the report from being challenged on procedural grounds before anyone looks at the number.

3. The inspection method is not disclosed

Photo-based and on-site appraisals are both legitimate. They produce different levels of certainty, and a court or opposing counsel is entitled to know which one they are looking at.

A report that does not state the inspection method — or that implies an on-site inspection when the appraiser never left their desk — is a liability for the attorney who submitted it. Our reports state the inspection method in the scope of work section. If it was photo-based, it says photo-based. If it was on-site, it says on-site, with the inspection date and location.

4. The appraiser's qualifications are not in the report

A value conclusion is only as credible as the person who signed it. If opposing counsel wants to challenge the appraisal, the first thing they will ask is: who is this person, what are their credentials, and why should the court accept their opinion of value?

Every report we produce includes an appraiser qualifications page: CV, ASCAA membership, USPAP conformity statement, and ASCAA-CERT-4246. The qualifications are in the document — not attached as a separate exhibit that can get separated from the file.

---

What a defensible estate vehicle appraisal looks like

Here is the structure of a report that survives scrutiny:

Cover page: Vehicle description, effective date (date of death), intended use (estate inventory / probate filing), intended users (named), inspection method (photo-based or on-site).

Scope of work: What was inspected, how, and what data sources were used. Comparable sales drawn from the period surrounding the effective date.

Condition section: Condition rating with supporting observations. If photo-based, the photos are referenced. If on-site, the inspection findings are documented.

Value conclusion: A single point value or a range, with the methodology stated. We use market comparison — comparable sales of similar vehicles in similar condition from the relevant time period.

Appraiser qualifications page: CV, certifications, USPAP conformity statement, ASCAA-CERT-4246.

Certification page: Signed, dated, with the effective date restated.

---

A note on collections

Multi-vehicle estates are common in our practice. A decedent who collected seriously may have left behind eight, twelve, or twenty vehicles — ranging from a daily driver to a numbers-matching muscle car that has not moved in thirty years.

We handle collections as a single engagement. One contact, one invoice, one report per vehicle (or a portfolio report if that is what the matter requires). We can work from photos and VIN packets for vehicles in storage, and schedule on-site inspections for vehicles that require physical examination.

Turnaround on a collection depends on the number of vehicles and the documentation available. We give a realistic timeline on the first call — not a number we cannot hit.

---

What to send us

To open an estate appraisal engagement:

• VIN, year, make, model, and mileage for each vehicle
• Date of death (the effective date)
• Photos of each vehicle — or an address for on-site inspection
• Case caption or estate name if you want it on the cover page
• Billing contact (attorney, firm, or estate)

Call or text (270) 790-7534. We will confirm scope, method, and turnaround before you commit.

---

On testimony

If the matter proceeds to a hearing and the appraisal is challenged, written declaration, deposition, and trial testimony are available by separate written engagement. Discuss availability on the initial call — before you set a hearing date that depends on it.

---

American Classic Appraisals is ASCAA-certified (ASCAA-CERT-4246). Reports are prepared in substantial conformity with USPAP. We appraise vehicles in all 50 states. For attorney engagements, visit /attorneys.