Independent Appraisal for Insurance Disputes — All 50 States
Total Loss & Appraisal Clause
When the insurance company's offer doesn't match what your vehicle is actually worth, you have a contractual right to fight back. We serve as your independent appraiser — building the certified value file and invoking the appraisal clause on your behalf.
$196k+
added to client settlements across documented claims
Call Shawn Directly
(270) 790-7534ASCAA-CERT-4246
Certified appraiser credential
USPAP Compliant
Prepared in substantial conformity with USPAP 2025–2026
Hagerty Approved
On Hagerty's approved appraiser list
Since 1993
Appraising vehicles for 30+ years
Who This Page Is For
You don't need a classic car to use this service. We work with owners of any vehicle — modern cars, trucks, motorcycles, RVs, and collector vehicles — who believe their insurer's total loss offer is too low.
Your insurer declared a total loss
The carrier's offer is based on their valuation — not necessarily yours. If the number doesn't reflect your vehicle's actual market value, you can dispute it before you accept.
The offer doesn't account for condition or upgrades
Carriers often use database averages that ignore documented upgrades, low mileage, exceptional condition, or recent restoration work. A certified appraisal puts those factors on the record.
You have a collector or specialty vehicle
Agreed-value and stated-value policies exist precisely because standard market databases can't price a numbers-matching muscle car, a custom build, or a low-production vehicle accurately.
You haven't signed anything yet
The moment you endorse the settlement check, the claim is closed in most states. If you're reading this before signing, you still have options.
What Is the Appraisal Clause?
Most auto insurance policies contain an appraisal clause — a provision that allows either party to demand an independent appraisal when there is a dispute over the vehicle's value. You appoint your own appraiser. The carrier appoints theirs. If the two appraisers disagree, a neutral umpire makes the final determination. The process is binding. Most carriers count on policyholders not knowing this right exists.
Key facts
- It is a contractual right — not a favor the carrier grants you
- It must be invoked in writing before you sign any release
- You pay for your appraiser; the carrier pays for theirs
- If an umpire is needed, that cost is split between both parties
- The umpire's determination is final and binding on both sides
Read the full guide: How to invoke the appraisal clause →
How We Work Your Claim
Step 01
Call Before You Sign Anything
Reach Shawn at (270) 790-7534. Tell him the vehicle, the carrier's offer, and where things stand. He'll tell you honestly whether invoking the appraisal clause makes sense for your situation — and what it's likely to cost versus what you stand to gain.
Step 02
We Review Your Policy
We pull the appraisal clause language from your specific policy. Not all clauses are identical — timing requirements, demand procedures, and umpire selection rules vary by carrier and state. We know what to look for.
Step 03
We Build Your Value File
We prepare a certified appraisal documenting your vehicle's actual market value — using comparable sales, condition analysis, documented upgrades, and market data the carrier's database missed. This is the foundation of your dispute.
Step 04
We Invoke the Clause on Your Behalf
We draft and deliver the written demand to the carrier. We serve as your appointed appraiser throughout the process — communicating with the carrier's appraiser and, if necessary, participating in umpire selection.
Step 05
Resolution
The two appraisers attempt to agree on value. If they cannot, the umpire decides. The result is binding. In most cases, disputes are resolved between the two appraisers without reaching the umpire stage.
Any Vehicle. Any Carrier.
We handle appraisal clause disputes for all vehicle types — not just classics.
Classic & Collector Cars
Muscle cars, hot rods, imports, pre-war, European
Modern Cars & Daily Drivers
Late-model sedans, coupes, SUVs, sports cars
Trucks & Diesels
Pickup trucks, diesel work trucks, commercial trucks
Motorcycles
Harley-Davidson, Indian, Triumph, BMW, sport bikes
RVs & Motorhomes
Class A, B, C motorhomes, travel trailers, fifth wheels
Specialty & Custom Builds
Restomod, custom fabrication, low-production vehicles
Carriers We've Worked Against
Our certified appraisals are accepted by all major insurance carriers. We have experience with disputes involving:
What We Will Not Promise
We will not guarantee a specific dollar outcome. No honest appraiser can. What we will do is build the strongest possible certified value file, invoke your contractual rights correctly, and represent your position with documented evidence throughout the process. The result depends on the facts of your vehicle and your claim — and we'll tell you honestly what we think before you commit to anything.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the appraisal clause in an insurance policy?+
How do I invoke the appraisal clause?+
I already cashed the check. Can I still dispute the claim?+
Does this work for modern cars, not just classics?+
What does it cost to use the appraisal clause?+
How long does the appraisal clause process take?+
My carrier says my vehicle is only worth what their system shows. Is that final?+
Don't Sign Until You've Made This Call
Once you cash that check, the claim is closed. If the number feels wrong, call Shawn before you do anything else. He'll tell you honestly what your options are.